Skip to main content

Facade Local Law 11

Compare Local Law 11 NYC Bids on the Same Scope

Facade bids rarely describe the same job. One counts every lintel, another says as needed; one includes the sidewalk shed, another leaves it out. We review bids from any contractor, including ones we did not write, and line them up against your report so the board can see what each number actually buys.

Which Contractor's Bid Should We Choose?

Before the vote, put every bid on one scope. Here is how we do it.

What Is a Local Law 11 NYC Bid Review?

A bid review checks each contractor’s proposal against the conditions in your FISP report and against each other. We look at what is included and what is left out, how quantities are stated, which repair methods are named, and how the work will be accessed, protected and documented. The result is a side-by-side comparison the board can read in one sitting.

We review bids whether or not we end up doing the work. The aim is a fair comparison, so the price difference between bids reflects real differences in scope and quality rather than missing lines that will come back later as change orders.

Small team reviewing building plans together at a table

1. Same Scope, Then Price

Bids only compare fairly once they price the same list of conditions.

2. Look for What Is Missing

Exclusions and as-needed quantities hide more cost than the headline number shows.

3. The Board Decides

We set out the facts side by side; the choice of contractor stays with the board.

How a Facade Bid Review Works inn NYC

Building a Common Scope

We start from the report and list each condition with its location and rating. Each bid is then mapped to that list, line by line, so it is clear which items a bid covers, which it skips and which it adds.

Testing Quantities and Methods

We check whether quantities are counted or guessed, whether the repair methods fit what the inspector or engineer asked for, and whether materials are named. A bid that says repair lintels as required is not the same as one that lists each lintel replacement with galvanized steel and new flashing.

Reading the Fine Print

Exclusions, allowances, payment terms, insurance, shed duration and close-out records are where bids differ most. We set these out in plain language, so the board knows what it would be signing and which questions to put to each contractor before the vote.

Bid Review Checklist for Boards and Managers

Six things to confirm in every bid before it goes to a vote.

A Bid Comparison Template You Can Use

Use these rows to line up two bids before the board meets. The bid columns are left blank on purpose; fill them in from each proposal.

What to Check Bid A Bid B

Condition List: Is every report condition listed, with its location and rating?

 

 

Quantities: Are lintels, anchors and units counted, and is pointing measured?

 

 

Repair Methods: Does each line name the method, such as replace, reset or patch?

 

 

Access and Shed: Which access method is used, and for how long is the shed included?

 

 

Permits and Plans: Who files the DOB permits, the Tenant Protection Plan and any landmark filing?

 

 

Hidden Conditions: How are extra quantities priced if they are found once the wall is opened?

 

 

Exclusions: What is left out, such as engineering, window work or interior repairs?

 

 

Close-Out: Are dated photos and documents for the amended report included?

 

 

Bid Comparison Mistakes That Lead to Change Orders

Change orders on facade jobs usually trace back to a bid that looked complete but was not.

Comparing Totals Only

Two totals mean little until both bids price the same conditions and quantities.

Accepting As Needed Quantities

Open-ended lines leave the final cost to whatever is found on the wall.

Ignoring Shed Duration

A bid with a short shed period may simply move that cost into later change orders.

Skipping the Exclusions Page

Engineering, permits or close-out records left out of one bid make it look cheaper than it is.

Bid Reviews Written for Board Meetings

The comparison is written for the people who have to vote on it.

A One-Page Summary

A short comparison the board can read before the meeting starts.

Questions for Each Bidder

A list of points each contractor should answer in writing.

Available at the Meeting

We can walk the board through the comparison when asked.

Holding Two or Three Facade Bids?

Send them with your FISP report, and we will line them up on one scope.

What You Receive From a Bid Review

Whether or not we bid on the job ourselves, the review gives you five working documents.

Common Scope

One list of report conditions that every bid is measured against.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Each bid mapped line by line, with gaps and extras marked.

Schedule Check

How each bid’s timeline fits the Unsafe and SWARMP dates.

Insurance Review

Coverage limits and additional insured wording compared.

Close-Out Terms

Which bids commit to the records your inspector needs.

A Typical Bid Review for a Condo Board

Low-angle view of an older apartment building facade with several balconies

This example shows how a bid review usually unfolds. It describes a typical project of this kind, not a specific building.

Scope: Three bids for balcony slab repairs, railing anchors and cast stone panels on a mid-rise condo

Phases: A common scope built from the report, each bid mapped line by line, and written questions sent to every bidder

Outcome: The board compared the bids on equal terms and chose a contractor with the shed, permits and close-out records included

Questions About Facade Bid Reviews NYC

Yes. We review bids from any contractor, whether or not we end up doing the work, and compare them against your report on the same terms.

Your FISP report, each bid with its attachments and exclusions, and any engineer's drawings or specifications. A site visit helps confirm quantities and access.

A much lower bid often prices fewer quantities, leaves out the shed or permits, or relies on open-ended allowances. The comparison shows whether the gap is a real saving or missing scope.

We set out how each bid compares on scope, quantities, methods, schedule, insurance and close-out. The choice stays with the board, and we answer any questions it has.

Yes, if the board asks us to. Our own estimate is built on the same common scope, so it can be compared line by line with the others.

Services That Pair With a Bid Review NYC

What drives the price of a facade project, and how our estimate is built.

Scopes, alternates and records a board can vote on.

Brick, lintels, parapets, terra cotta and fire escapes, repaired item by item.

Send your FISP report and book a site visit.